Review: An All-Star “Don Carlo” from Plácido Domingo and Friends – Los Angeles Opera, September 29, 2018

Any opera company in the world certainly would have jumped at the chance to mount Verdi’s “Don Carlo” if the cast that Los Angeles Opera had assembled were available – Mexican tenor Ramón Vargas in the title role, Puerto Rican soprano Ana María Martínez as Elisabetta di Valois, Russian soprano Anna Smirnova as the Princess Eboli, Italian basso Ferruccio Furlanetto as Philip II, the American bassos Morris Robinson and Soloman Howard respectively as the Grand Inquisitor and Carlo Quinto, with the Los Angeles Opera music director, the esteemed Maestro James Conlon conducting.

It was, however, the other principal cast member, the superstar Plácido Domingo, as Rodrigo, Marquis of Posa, that was the impetus for the Los Angeles Opera choosing “Don Carlo” for its season opener. Stars in the operatic firmament gathered in Los Angeles for the honor of sharing the stage with Domingo, certainly the most universally revered of contemporary opera singers.

Plácido Domingo’s Posa

As the Marquis of Posa, Domingo, at age 77, demonstrated a lyric baritone that has retained a youthful bloom. His legato is smooth and devoid of any hint of “beat” or vocal disrepair that bedevils so many artists in the later years of their career.

[Below: Plácido Domingo as Rodrigo, Marquis of Posa; edited image, based on a Cory Weaver photograph, courtesy of the Los Angeles Opera.]

Domingo’s acting as Posa magnificently projected this extraordinary figure – a Spanish grandee with swagger who dares to scold the king; a man, philosophically in tune with the 18th century Enlightenment, who tries to reform the Spain of the 16th century Inquisition with fatal consequences.

Posa has one of the most affecting death scenes in all of Italian opera. Domingo delivered Posa’s final aria Io morrò, ma lieto in core with memorable poignancy.

The role of Posa, as with the each of the roles in this great masterwork of Verdi, requires a singer who can convey a range of emotions vocally, while performing Verdi’s luxurious melodies beautifully. Domingo brought experience, eloquence and vocal control to the task. The future will refer to Domingo’s “legendary” Posa performance, and I can confirm to the future that the attribution is deserved.

Ramón Vargas’ Don Carlo, Ana María Martínez’ Elisabetta di Valois and Anna Smirnova’s Princess Eboli

In the title role of Don Carlo, tenor Ramón Vargas returned to the Los Angeles Opera after a nearly two-decade absence, taking on a role that Domingo himself had sung with the Los Angeles Opera in 1990. Vargas, as he moves into his mid-50s, continues to concentrate his repertory of operatic roles in the lyric repertory, a strategy that augurs vocal longevity.

Vargas’ bright, appealing lyric tenor melded beautifully with Domingo in the extraordinary series of scenes between Carlo and Posa – the close harmony of their anthem of friendship Dio, che nell’alma in fondere, the dramatic tension of the auto da fe scene where Posa disarms the defiant Carlo, and, memorably, their last scene together where Posa is assassinated in Carlos’ prison cell.

Vargas’ Carlo is enmeshed in the opera’s central plot, in which Carlo’s father, for affairs of state,  takes Carlo’s intended bride, the French royal Elisabetta di Valois (sung convincingly by soprano Ana María Martínez) as his own Queen, thereby estranging his son and heir, the lovelorn Carlo.

[Below: Don Carlo (Ramón Vargas, right) is distressed at the seeming aloofness of Queen Elisabetta of Valois; edited image, based on a Cory Weaver photograph, courtesy of the Los Angeles Opera.]

This is the third opportunity that I have had to review an Ana María Martínez performance of Elisabetta di Valois. [See Review: A Legendary Performance of “Don Carlo” at the San Francisco Opera, June 12, 2016  in which I described her singing of Elisabetta’s great final scene aria Tu che la vanita, conoscesti del mondo as “electrifying”.]

Martinez was regal, appearing reserved while exuding a suppressed inner passion. She dominated the opera’s final scene in which she delivered her great aria with distinction.

[Below: Ana María Martínez as Queen Elisabetta di Valois; edited image, based on a Cory Weaver photograph, courtesy of the Los Angeles Opera.]

Russian mezzo-soprano Anna Smirnova was a fiery Princess Eboli, one of the most complex of Verdi’s seconda donna roles, with a searing delivery of Eboli’s dramatic aria, O don fatale!

I had been impressed with Smirnova’s Amneris six years ago in Chicago [An Admirable “Aida”: Hui He, Berti, Smirnova, Kelsey Are Impressive – Lyric Opera of Chicago, March 15, 2012] and found her Eboli equally satisfying.

[Below: Anna Smirnova as the Princess Eboli; edited image, based on a Cory Weaver photograph, courtesy of the Los Angeles Opera.]

Ferruccio Furlanetto’s King Philip II, Morris Robinson’s Grand Inquisitor and Soloman Howard’s Carlo Quinto

The season opening and second “Don Carlo” performances featured the appearance of Italian basso Ferruccio Furlanetto as Carlo’s father, King Philip II. Among the most preeminent of late 20th and early 21st century operatic bassos, Furlanetto defines the Philip II role.

Furlanetto delivered King Philip’s soul-searching monologue Ella giammai m’amò compellingly – evoking Philip’s depression about his family estrangement, weariness with his kingly responsibilities, contemplation of his death – a masterful performance that was another highlight of the extraordinary evening.

[Below: Ferruccio Furlanetto as King Philip II; edited image, based on a Cory Weaver photograph, courtesy of the Los Angeles Opera.]

At monologue’s end, the blind, sinister Grand Inquisitor, in a chilling portrayal vocally and dramatically by basso Morris Robinson, is brought into the King’s presence in one of Verdi’s most extraordinary operatic scenes – the King is absolved of sin in advance should he decide to murder his son Carlo, while the Grand Inquisitor requires that the King also to surrender the free-thinking Posa to the Inquisition.

[Below: the Grand Inquisitor (Morris Robinson, left) suggests that King Philip II (Ferruccio Furlanetto, right) is not immune from being charged with heresy; edited image, based on a Cory Weaver photograph, courtesy of the Los Angeles Opera.]

In the seven extant versions of “Don Carlo” (four in French as “Don Carlos”), several begin the opera at the French estate of  Fontainebleau. After this scene in France, the action moves to the Cloister of the Monastery of Saint Just in Spain. There, a friar (who may be Carlo Quinto – the Emperor Charles V – or his ghost) sings of the world’s vanity. The Milan version performed in Los Angeles has no introductory scene in France and begins and ends with the Saint Just scene.

Soloman Howard played the role of the mysterious friar in an otherworldly looking monk’s robe, whose face appears as a large skull. In the final notes of the opera, Robinson’s Grand Inquisitor and his followers cry out that the friar’s voice is that of Carlo Quinto and Vargas’ Don Carlo is pulled into his grandfather’s crypt to whatever fate awaits him.

[Below: Soloman Howard as a Friar, who may be the ghost of the Holy Roman Emperor Charles V; edited image, based on a Cory Weaver photograph, courtesy of the Los Angeles Opera.]

Ian Judge’s Production, Louisa Muller’s Revival and John Gunter’s Set Designs and Tim Goodchild’s Costumes

The production, created by the British team of Ian Judge (director), the late John Gunter (set designer) and Tim Goodchild (costume designer) dates from 2006. The sets consist mostly of arches that are repositioned for scene changes, above which are images of paintings in the Renaissance style. The production’s most striking image is a monstrous crucifix that descends above the crowd in the auto da fe scene. The revival was staged by Rhode Island director Louisa Muller.

[Below: the burning of heretics takes place in the auto da fe scene; edited image, based on a Cory Weaver photograph, courtesy of the Los Angeles Opera.]

Maestro James Conlon and the Los Angeles Opera Orchestra and Chorus

The Los Angeles Opera Orchestra and Chorus was conducted by Maestro James Conlon, who had just assumed the title of Los Angeles Opera music director when the Ian Judge production was first produced. In the dozen years since Conlon became music director, he has built the Los Angeles Opera Orchestra into a world class organization.

This opera in its Milan version is a favorite of Maestro Conlon and the Orchestra responded to his leadership brilliantly. The Los Angeles Opera chorus, which is directed by Maestro Grant Gershon, displayed command of Verdi’s masterful choral writing, particularly in the big choral passages of the auto da fe scene.


I enthusiastically recommend the opera, cast and production for both the veteran opera goer and person new to opera, and especially recommend that persons able to obtain tickets to Placido Domingo’s performances as Posa should do so.